Why N.T. Wright says God changes his mind

Start here

This is a study companion to the video "Why N.T. Wright Says God Changes His Mind." It is for the person who was handed a God who cannot be moved. Maybe you were told that God is in control, and on the worst day of your life that sentence made things heavier, because it meant God wanted what happened. Maybe you were told that prayer never changes God, only you, and you kept praying without quite knowing why. It is also for the reader who followed a tidy system of theology all the way to the bottom and found a God there they could not love. If any of that is you, you are in good company, and the Bible has more to say than you were told.

Here is how to use it. Watch the video first, because it carries Wright's own voice. Then open your Bible to 1 Samuel 15 and keep it open. Read "The teaching" straight through, since it carries the whole argument by itself. After that, work through "The passages" slowly with a pen, checking every quotation against your own Bible. Save "Questions to sit with" for last, and answer them on paper.

One thing before we start. Salvation comes through faith in Jesus, whatever you conclude about this question. I have friends all over the map on this who love the Lord and love people well. The view I hold, usually called the open view, sits outside the majority position in church history, and I hold it because of passages like the ones in this guide. So read with your Bible open and your heart kind toward the people who read it differently.

This matters because what you believe about whether God can be moved shapes two very practical things: how you pray, and what you think God wanted on your worst day. If God's mind was settled before the world began, your prayers are a kind of performance and your tragedies were part of his plan. If God truly responds, your prayers are part of how the story goes, and your grief is something he feels with you.